Ok When you read the cover like this - This book sounds brilliant ... When we formed our book club each member was to pick a book so to start us off we all decided on this Book to read ... A little bit of a love story (Some even say that it the greatest love story to cross time) and a little bit of fantasy ( with the time travelling angle).
This book got so many good reviews and everyone seemed to love it that when I was half way through the book I thought I most be reading a different book .... There are moments in the book that I thought OK this could get interesting and then the writer wouldn't follow through with the story line .... There is some bad language and a little bit of sex in the novel as well ....
I was sorely disappointed with this book because the basic idea is really good and could have been a great book ... I was so frustrated and thought Henry the main character to be totally selfish that by the end of the book I couldn't have cared what happened to him ....
There is going to be a movie made of the book with lovely Eric Bana ... It will be interesting to see if the movie will be true to the book ... I am kinda hoping that it isn't .....
I rate this book unfortunately 1*
2 comments:
Hey, you guys got a shelfari! Way to go! Can I add you as a friend?
Thanks for the review-- I had heard good things from my book club, but of course, nobody mentioned the language and sex because that's perfectly permissible and usually expected in a top selling book these days. Garbage. And is P.S.I Love you the book that inspired the recent-ish-ly made movie?
Yup you can add us as a friend .... Good to have you onboard ... This months read is PS I love you loosely based on the movie ... We get together in a couple of weeks to discuss it ... Don't know how I feel about that book I may get very homesick as I am from Ireland myself :)
Post a Comment